Item |
Chunyul Energy
[as of 13 Nov 2008] |
Oil boiler
[as of 11 Jan 2009] |
Gas boiler
[as of 01 Dec 2008] |
Sheath heater
[as of 13 Nov 2008] |
Film heating
[as of 13 Nov 2008] |
Heating method |
2-wire heating cable,
enclosed warm-water heating |
Warm-water circulation
heating using an oil boiler |
1-wire direct
heating method |
Direct heating using
carbon heating film |
Material of
radiation pipe |
Silicon, Teflon, Fiber Cover,
XL Heating Pipe |
XL warm-water pipe |
Silicon and
Magnesium Oxide |
Polyethylene carbon
laminating |
Heat generator |
2-wire heating warm-
water heating |
Warm-water
circulation heating |
1-wire high-temperature heating |
(Joule's Heat + Warm Water
+ Vapor + Weak Vacuum) |
Joule's heat |
Joule's Heat + Carbon |
Daily energy
consumption for
3.3§³
(based on abut
21¡É of indoor
temperature) |
103 kw/day(15h)
|
34.6
L/day(15h) |
32.9 N§©
/day(15h) |
227 kw/day(15h) |
272 kw/day(15h) |
£Ü8,312 |
£Ü 31,693 |
£Ü 23,359 |
£Ü 18,319 |
£Ü29,542 |
100% |
381% |
281% |
220% |
355% |
Maintenance
Cost |
Not required |
Cost for regular part
replacement and A/S by
heat engineer |
In case of trouble with the product, product
replacement after bottom removal and full
bottom construction |
Safety |
No requirement for
overheating-preventive device |
Requirement for a safety
device to prevent freeze
rupture
|
Overheating preventive
device is not required. |
Weak to moisture
Overheating preventive
device is not required. |
Generation of
electronic wave |
Acquisition of EFF Certification -
European international
electronic-wave standards |
None |
Electronic-wave blocking
device is not required. |
Facility work
Lifecycle |
30 years of lifecycle (100%) |
7 years of lifecycle(420%) |
10 years of lifecycle |
Durability |
Good durability of heat
transmission wire with 80¡É
of low-temperature heating
(more than 30 years) |
Short lifecycle due to
many mechanical units |
Heat-transmission wire should be replaced
due to high-temperature heating |
Maintainability |
Simple replacement and
repair through inspection boxes
|
Regular maintenance work
such as pipe cleaning is
required. |
Difficult replacement and repair |
Lifecycle
extension index |
1 |
4.2 |
2.9 |
3 |
Usability |
Prevention of freeze rupture
of indoor/outdoor heating
and industrial pipes |
For indoor heating only |
Prevention of freeze rupture
of indoor/outdoor heating
and industrial pipes |
For indoor
heating only |